Breaking the Spell: Religion as a Natural Phenomenon
17 July 2007
In Breaking the Spell: Religion as a Natural Phenomenon, Daniel Dennett tries to answer the question, ‘Why are we religious?’ Looking at the issue from the standpoint of evolutionary biology, Dennett hopes to explain the origin and endurance of religion naturalistically.
As I’ve explained in my article on the supposed evolution of belief, I’m not completely opposed to this kind of project, nor am I particularly concerned about the results. There is no reason for Christians to worry about theories which naturalistically explain the tendency for people to be religious. There are several reasons for this, not least of which is the fact that providing explanations of the origin of beliefs are not grounds for dismissing the belief. To make such a dismissal would be to commit the genetic fallacy. The rationality of any given belief must be analyzed on its own merits.
And this is what Dennett fails miserably to do, which would be fine except for the fact that he promises to do it. If Dennett were merely describing the ways religion could naturalistically arrive, then there would be no problem. But the book is not quite neutral on the subject, and it is clear that Dennett thinks that there are actually good reasons to reject religious beliefs. In one short section, Dennett takes on the task of refuting natural theology. Yet, even by his own admission, the section contains little or no reasoning- it only gives broad pronouncements. To introduce the section, Dennett writes,
“At long last I turn to the promised consideration of arguments for the existence of God. And, having reviewed the obstacles- diplomatic, logical, psychological, and tactical- facing anybody who wants to do this constructively, I will give just a brief bird’s-eye view of the domain of inquiry, expressing my own verdicts but not the reasoning that has gone into them, and providing references to a few pieces that may not be familiar to many.” [240]
Did you catch that? Dennett admits that he is not going to provide any reasoning, but merely pronounce his own verdicts on the matter! Why on earth should he do that? It’s already clear at this point in the book that Dennett is an atheist, so we are already aware of his ‘verdicts.’ What we need is some solid reasoning.
And of course, what he does offer us on this subject is extremely weak. He brushes off historical arguments, claiming that they are manifestly question-begging. Well, some of the most unsophisticated ones are, but this does not show that all historical argumentation is useless. Dennett apparently thinks that the only historical arguments are the ones of the fashion:
1. The Bible is God’s word.
2. God makes no mistakes.
3. Therefore, the Bible makes no mistakes.
And, therefore (of course), we know that God exists, because the Bible tells us so! Of course these sorts of arguments are absolute trash, but what about arguments for the Resurrection of Jesus Christ, which do not assume that the Bible is perfect but merely considers the books of the New Testament (and others) as historical sources. Dennett probably doesn’t think that a good case for the resurrection can be made, but the point is simply that he cannot brush off all forms of historical argumentation as if there is nothing substantial to discuss.
Philosophy is actually Dennett’s primary expertise, so we should expect him to be particularly qualified to discuss philosophical arguments for God’s existence. Here, again, he falls far short. He brushes off the Cosmological Argument with simplistic objections like ‘What caused God?’ Then he basically dismisses the whole argument as too ‘arcane’ to bother with. He doesn’t even do this much when discussing the Design Argument, which he claims to have covered ‘quite extensively’ in his book Darwin’s Dangerous Idea, and he decides to merely provide a summary from that book rather than offer any reason for us to think that the Design Argument is flawed.
And that’s all there is to say about that. Whatever the use of this book, it certainly provides no compelling reason to think that God doesn’t exist.
Besides developing an account of the naturalistic emergence and evolution of religious belief, Breaking the Spell also attempts to address the question, ‘Is religion good for us?’ Dennett admits that much more research needs to be done before conclusions can be reached, an admission that he makes concerning almost every topic and theory discussed throughout the entire book. Yet, despite the fact that the data is too limited and the variables too many to come to a conclusion on the matter, Dennett still seems, at least implicitly, to conclude that religion is bad for us, or at least is seriously problematic.
Dennett does get quite a bit right. He is right that we should not try to shield religious beliefs and protect them from skeptical or reflective inquiry. He is right that we should pursue a great deal of research into these topics. I am personally not afraid of such scrutiny of my religious beliefs. But Dennett has a long way to go if he hopes to convince me that religion is only a natural phenomenon.
——————————————————————————————————————
“provides no compelling reason to think that God doesn’t exist”
iirc Dennett’s book explicitly does not seek to persuade anyone whether or not God exists.
The whole thrust of Dennett’s book is that religion should be studies as a natural phenomenom, setting out the questions that should be asked, and whatever tentative incomplete answers seem to be available now.
— anob Nov 6, 07:46 PM #
anob,
Unfortunately, Dennett does seek to persuade people that there is no good reason to believe that God exists- why else include a chapter attempting to refute natural theology?
— Kyle Nov 7, 01:48 PM #
I haven’t read this book yet and I’m wondering if anybody can help me understand something.
Does Dennett discuss why nature would instill desires within humans that nature itself could not fulfill?
As Gregory Boyd noted: Nature gave us sexual desires and fulfills them with sex. Nature gave us thirst and fulfills it with water. Nature gave us hunger and fulfills it with food. etc.
Why would nature give humans such a powerful yearning for “something out there” (something “beyond” us) if there really wasn’t something out there?
I’m not saying this proves God’s existence. But if Dennett is right about the origin of religion, then it think it’s a strong argument that there really is something out there. Whatever it may be is something that would have to be ascertained by other fields of inquiry.
— Patrick Dec 13, 03:36 AM #
AtCfk1 yjjxtyfhdsmz, [url=http://iiqmhjcqoqry.com/]iiqmhjcqoqry[/url], [link=http://nrtfcjwbbmye.com/]nrtfcjwbbmye[/link], http://qnnpxdrtwupu.com/
— vlvoadqrnhv Mar 23, 02:52 AM #
hzwyalyh http://jmsqdmtp.com ptdtfakc vfyqjkii lwsngymr [URL=http://qiwztfix.com]suzxgduo[/URL]
— btqmhwkr Apr 18, 02:47 PM #
Be courteous to all, but intimate with few; and let those few be well tried before you give them your confidence.
— xenical online Apr 20, 03:43 PM #
The toughest question has always been, “How do you get your ideas?” How do you answer that? It’s like asking runners how they run, or singers how they sing. They just do it!
— generic effexor Apr 20, 07:15 PM #
Have no fear of perfection – you’ll never reach it.
— buy tramadol Apr 20, 10:51 PM #
I know that you believe that you understood what you think I said, but I am not sure you realize that what you heard is not what I meant.
— sonata Apr 21, 02:18 AM #
Glory is fleeting, but obscurity is forever.
— diflucan Apr 21, 05:45 AM #
Let not the sands of time get in your lunch.
— paroxetine Apr 21, 09:19 AM #
The Past is to be respected and acknoledged, but not to be worshiped. It is our future in which we will find our greatness.
— purchase soma Apr 21, 01:04 PM #
We inhereit from our ancestors gifts so often taken for granted… Each of us contains within… this inheritance of soul. We are links between the ages, containing past and present expectations, sacred memories and future promise.
— buy zoloft Apr 21, 04:40 PM #
You can tell a lot about a fellow’s character by his way of eating jellybeans.
— buy hydrocodone online Apr 21, 08:14 PM #
Self-importance is our greatest enemy. Think about it – what weakens us is feeling offended by the deeds and misdeeds of our fellowmen. Our self-importance requires that we spend most of our lives offended by someone.
— generic cialis betweenness menophobia Apr 21, 11:48 PM #
Flattery is like cologne water, to be smelt of, not swallowed.
— fosamax Apr 22, 03:22 AM #
How to Raise your I.Q. by Eating Gifted Children
— viagra Apr 22, 06:59 AM #
Somebody has to do something, and it’s just incredibly pathetic that it has to be us.
— venlafaxine Apr 22, 10:34 AM #
You don’t get anything clean without getting something else dirty.
— lasix Apr 22, 02:09 PM #
Be sincere; be brief; be seated.
— tramadol Apr 22, 05:52 PM #
History is indeed little more than the register of the crimes, follies and misfortunes of mankind.
— tadalafil Apr 22, 09:36 PM #
The gambling known as business looks with austere disfavor upon the business known as gambling.
— buy viagra online Apr 23, 01:36 AM #
Fig Newton: The force required to accelerate a fig 39.37 inches per sec.
— buy propecia Apr 23, 05:38 AM #
From the moment I picked up your book until I laid it down, I was convulsed with laughter. Some day I intend reading it.
— amoxicillin Apr 23, 09:10 AM #
Intimacy is what makes a marriage, not a ceremony, not a piece of paper from the state.
— zyloprim Apr 23, 12:42 PM #
Liberals are very broadminded: they are always willing to give careful consideration to both sides of the same side.
— diazepam Apr 23, 04:17 PM #
Beginning today, treat everyone you meet as if they were going to be dead by midnight. Extend them all the care, kindness and understanding you can muster. Your life will never be the same again.
— prevacid Apr 23, 07:54 PM #
To believe in God or in a guiding force because someone tells you to is the height of stupidity. We are given senses to receive our information within. With our own eyes we see, and with our own skin we feel. With our intelligence, it is intended that we understand. But each person must puzzle it out for himself or herself.
— metformin Apr 23, 11:32 PM #
I never met anybody who said when they were a kid, “I wanna grow up and be a critic.”
— buspar Apr 24, 03:06 AM #
Summer afternoon – Summer afternoon… the two most beautiful words in the English language.
— fluconazole Apr 24, 07:00 AM #
For me, it’s that I contributed, ... That I’m on this planet doing some good and making people happy. That’s to me the most important thing, that my hour of television is positive and upbeat and an antidote for all the negative stuff going on in life.
— finasteride Apr 24, 10:37 AM #
A man is too apt to forget that in this world he cannot have everything. A choice is all that is left him.
— cheap levitra Apr 24, 02:24 PM #
Do what you feel in your heart to be right – for you’ll be criticized anyway. You’ll be damned if you do, and damned if you don’t.
— sildenafil Apr 24, 06:07 PM #
No one goes there nowadays, it’s too crowded.
— generic ultram Apr 24, 09:44 PM #
The movies are the only business where you can go out front and applaud yourself.
— purchase soma online Apr 25, 01:20 AM #
History is indeed little more than the register of the crimes, follies and misfortunes of mankind.
— buy alprazolam online Apr 25, 04:34 AM #
Work saves us from three great evils: boredom, vice and need.
— xenical online Apr 25, 08:15 AM #
Under democracy one party always devotes its chief energies to trying to prove that the other party is unfit to rule – and both commonly succeed, and are right.
— advil Apr 25, 11:50 AM #
Love is the triumph of imagination over intelligence.
— cheap levitra Apr 25, 03:24 PM #
There are worse things in life than death. Have you ever spent an evening with an insurance salesman?
— order cialis Apr 25, 07:02 PM #
Feeling grateful to or appreciative of someone or something in your life actually attracts more of the things that you appreciate and value into your life.
— generic viagra Apr 25, 10:34 PM #
I sent the club a wire stating, PLEASE ACCEPT MY RESIGNATION. I DON’T WANT TO BELONG TO ANY CLUB THAT WILL ACCEPT ME AS A MEMBER.
— buy xenical retractor lipasuria Apr 26, 02:09 AM #
The meeting of two personalities is like the contact of two chemical substances: if there is any reaction, both are transformed.
— motrin Apr 26, 06:06 AM #
College isn’t the place to go for ideas.
— glucophage Apr 26, 09:47 AM #
Truly great madness cannot be achieved without significant intelligence.
— zopiclone Apr 26, 01:28 PM #
My pessimism extends to the point of even suspecting the sincerity of the pessimists.
— atorvastatin Apr 26, 05:07 PM #
The aim of life is self-development. To realize one’s nature perfectly – that is what each of us is here for.
— prinivil Apr 26, 08:50 PM #
Our patience will achieve more than our force.
— escitalopram Apr 27, 12:33 AM #
History teaches us that men and nations behave wisely once they have exhausted all other alternatives.
— allopurinol Apr 27, 04:14 AM #
That man is the richest whose pleasures are the cheapest.
— generic phentermine Apr 27, 08:04 AM #
Nothing inspires forgiveness quite like revenge.
— buy carisoprodol online Apr 27, 11:49 AM #
Do something every day that you don’t want to do; this is the golden rule for acquiring the habit of doing your duty without pain.
— tylenol Apr 27, 03:22 PM #
Posterity is as likely to be wrong as anyone else.
— escitalopram Apr 27, 06:59 PM #
Life is a great big canvas; throw all the paint on it you can.
— order vicodin Apr 27, 10:41 PM #
There are no wise few. Every aristocracy that has ever existed has behaved, in all essential points, exactly like a small mob.
— fluconazole Apr 28, 02:19 AM #
The toughest thing about success is that you’ve got to keep on being a success. Talent is only a starting point in this business. You’ve got to keep on working that talent. Someday I’ll reach for it and it won’t be there.
— vicodin online Apr 28, 06:01 AM #
A man can do all things if he but wills them.
— buy alprazolam Apr 28, 09:41 AM #
Zoo: An excellent place to study the habits of human beings.
— montelukast Apr 28, 12:51 PM #
I find television very educating. Every time somebody turns on the set, I go into the other room and read a book.
— buy vicodin online Apr 28, 04:58 PM #
I guess we’d be living in a boring, perfect world if everybody wished everybody else well.
— generic prilosec Apr 28, 08:37 PM #
scuk; free casino games 8OO; online roulette 395; home owner insurance coverage icsl; cialis online, >:-))); health insurance =
OOO; online slots 567; casino roulette, idrz; online gambling, 29476; acomplia weight loss drug relnn; gambling hiecw; online casino 8((; best online casino nlc; cheapest home insurance :-]]; purchase fioricet xazdss; cheap auto insurance 0372; fluoxetine 788; cheap viagra =-)); life insurance quotes 20769; acomplia, 637586; zovirax, =-D; free casino games sfxl; generic viagra :-DD;— scuko38 Apr 29, 12:29 AM #
The trouble with being poor is that it takes up all of your time.
— buspar Apr 29, 12:43 AM #
scuk; life insurance quotes >:-))); gambling 549; affordable health insurance 24166; health insurance 8-[[[; free slots =]]; free casino games %]; roulette 242; get free annual credit report mbhjs; online black jack pxcjif; online gambling =-); poker games 82088; car insurance qqkqcy; homeowners insurance =P; home owner insurance yiyybh; loans 519; secured credit cards %-))); casino online 973676; homeowner insurance, >:))); blackjack :
D; free poker >:-PP; cheap health insurance 584896; home owners insurance 8); car insurance quotes 249188; free credit check >:DDD; cheap auto insurance 524; insurance 172; auto insurance quotes, 71624; affordable health insurance 8PPP; no deposit casinos =-DD; online casinos alhl; generic viagra :))); gambling %-D; black jack 72640; free online auto insurance quotes :-DD; term life insurance[[; slots online, 750870; car insurance 392067; purchase cipro 740; allstate insurance (; cheap lorazepam :-DD; cheap car insurance >:]]]; insurance online xuglwg; online casino 8-O; annual free credit report 7958;— scuko101 Apr 29, 01:33 AM #
If you really do put a small value upon yourself, rest assured that the world will not raise your price.
— danazol Apr 29, 04:35 AM #
For visions come not to polluted eyes.
— order phentermine online Apr 29, 08:11 AM #
To have a right to do a thing is not at all the same as to be right in doing it.
— zyrtec Apr 29, 11:59 AM #
obUegz fbmnehhcapwt, [url=http://satwjdandpya.com/]satwjdandpya[/url], [link=http://ltxkvssebrpb.com/]ltxkvssebrpb[/link], http://dqwyihspmygs.com/
— ueocoiaupua Apr 29, 12:06 PM #
Even the best of friends need time apart.
— bextra shorten phthisiology Apr 29, 03:25 PM #
The supreme irony of life is that hardly anyone gets out of it alive.
— cheap xanax Apr 29, 07:07 PM #
I define comfort as self-acceptance. When we finally learn that self-care begins and ends with ourselves, we no longer demand sustenance and happiness from others.
— xenical Apr 29, 10:43 PM #
Lack of money is no obstacle. Lack of an idea is an obstacle.
— testosterone Apr 30, 02:25 AM #
Happiness is not a station you arrive at, but a manner of traveling.
— cheap tramadol online Apr 30, 06:11 AM #
Nobody is ever met at the airport when beginning a new adventure. It’s just not done.
— tramadol online Apr 30, 09:46 AM #
One of the lessons of history is that nothing is often a good thing to do and always a clever thing to say.
— cheap levitra Apr 30, 12:51 PM #
That would be a good thing for them to cut on my tombstone: Wherever she went, including here, it was against her better judgment.
— levitra Apr 30, 04:34 PM #
College isn’t the place to go for ideas.
— cheap viagra Apr 30, 08:12 PM #
His priority did not seem to be to teach them what he knew, but rather to impress upon them that nothing, not even… knowledge, was foolproof.
— zanaflex May 1, 12:20 AM #
Reading well is one of the great pleasures that solitude can afford you.
— fioricet online May 1, 04:30 AM #
Make a decision, even if it’s wrong.
— cheap viagra online May 1, 08:01 AM #
Experience is that marvelous thing that enables you to recognize a mistake when you make it again.
— keflex May 1, 11:38 AM #
Enjoy your own life without comparing it with that of another.
— generic celexa May 1, 03:21 PM #
It’s wonderful what we can do if we’re always doing.
— cipro May 1, 06:57 PM #
We owe something to extravagance, for thrift and adventure seldom go hand in hand.
— viagra May 1, 06:57 PM #
Life is consciousness.
— lorazepam clipped foucherite May 1, 10:38 PM #
Let us so live that when we come to die even the undertaker will be sorry.
— lasix May 2, 02:16 AM #
Go through your phone book, call people and ask them to drive you to the airport. The ones who will drive you are your true friends. The rest aren’t bad people; they’re just acquaintances.
— cialis May 2, 05:53 AM #
A mother is not a person to lean on but a person to make leaning unnecessary.
— norco May 2, 09:34 AM #
He was one of those men who think that the world can be saved by writing a pamphlet.
— imitrex May 2, 12:51 PM #
The Past is to be respected and acknoledged, but not to be worshiped. It is our future in which we will find our greatness.
— order adipex May 2, 04:34 PM #
I?m telling you, things are getting out of hand. Or maybe I?m discovering that things were never in my hands.
— celecoxib May 2, 08:10 PM #
The summer night is like a perfection of thought.
— buy ambien online May 2, 11:50 PM #
Nothing is as certain as that the vices of leisure are gotten rid of by being busy.
— generic zyrtec May 3, 03:31 AM #
In the absences of a decent time machine, fiction remains the most sturdy vehicle for visiting other eras.
— valium May 3, 07:13 AM #
As a scientist, I am not sure anymore that life can be reduced to a class struggle, to dialectical materialism, or any set of formulas. Life is spontaneous and it is unpredictable, it is magical. I think that we have struggled so hard with the tangible that we have forgotten the intangible.
— buy alprazolam May 3, 10:44 AM #
What’s another word for Thesaurus?
— generic wellbutrin May 3, 02:03 PM #
Over the years your bodies become walking autobiographies, telling friends and strangers alike of the minor and major stresses of your lives.
— celecoxib May 3, 07:43 PM #
That man is the richest whose pleasures are the cheapest.
— buy carisoprodol online May 3, 11:15 PM #
I don’t like composers who think. It gets in the way of their plagiarism.
— alendronate May 4, 02:56 AM #
The moment we begin to fear the opinions of others and hesitate to tell the truth that is in us, and from motives of policy are silent when we should speak, the divine floods of light and life no longer flow into our souls.
— premarin May 4, 06:26 AM #
When I came back to Dublin I was courtmartialed in my absence and sentenced to death in my absence, so I said they could shoot me in my absence.
— alprazolam online May 4, 10:37 AM #
Never rely on the glory of the morning nor the smiles of your mother-in-law.
— alprazolam May 4, 02:03 PM #
Cheese – milk’s leap toward immortality.
— hoodia online annulation fated May 4, 05:34 PM #
Misquotations are the only quotations that are never misquoted.
— buy wellbutrin May 4, 09:02 PM #
Sometime they’ll give a war and nobody will come.
— zolpidem May 5, 12:40 AM #
The only time to buy these is on a day with no ‘y’ in it.
— azithromycin May 5, 04:08 AM #
Meetings are indispensable when you don’t want to do anything.
— advil May 5, 07:48 AM #
The problem with people who have no vices is that generally you can be pretty sure they’re going to have some pretty annoying virtues.
— purchase vicodin May 5, 11:50 AM #
To be willing to die for an idea is to set a rather high price on conjecture.
— sertraline May 5, 03:22 PM #
I was not a child prodigy, because a child prodigy is a child who knows as much when it is a child as it does when it grows up.
— esgic May 5, 06:34 PM #
The excellence of a gift lies in its appropriateness rather than in its value.
— allopurinol May 5, 10:04 PM #
Inspiration does exist, but it must find you working.
— zolpidem May 6, 01:43 AM #
Viagra pills online
viagra online
http://www.viagrausaonline.com/
[url=http://www.viagrausaonline.com/]viagra online[/url]
— Viagra May 6, 04:28 AM #
No.
— buy tramadol online May 6, 05:34 AM #
Posterity is as likely to be wrong as anyone else.
— nasacort May 6, 09:37 AM #
There are several good protections against temptations, but the surest is cowardice.
— sildenafil May 6, 01:26 PM #
The first precept was never to accept a thing as true until I knew it as such without a single doubt.
— buy levitra May 6, 05:08 PM #
I wrote myself a check for ten million dollars for acting services rendered and dated it Thanksgiving 1995. I put it in my wallet and it deteriorated. And then, just before Thanksgiving 1995, I found out I was going to make ten million dollars for Dumb & Dumber. I put that check in the casket with my father because it was our dream together.
— generic ambien May 6, 09:27 PM #
All movements go too far.
— finasteride May 7, 01:15 AM #
Hearing voices no one else can hear isn’t a good sign, even in the wizarding world.
— fluconazole May 7, 05:03 AM #
You can go a long way with bad legs and a good head.
— nexium online May 7, 08:44 AM #
The older I grow, the less important the comma becomes. Let the reader catch his own breath.
— kenalog May 7, 12:28 PM #
Could you imagine how horrible things would be if we always told others how we felt? Life would be intolerably bearable.
— purchase soma May 7, 04:22 PM #
Man is distinguished from all other creatures by the faculty of laughter.
— buy soma online May 7, 07:59 PM #
The nice thing about egotists is that they don’t talk about other people.
— sertraline May 7, 11:27 PM #
Get away from the crowd when you can. Keep yourself to yourself, if only for a few hours daily.
— sertraline dyedwhite pitch May 8, 03:05 AM #
It’s very hard to take yourself too seriously when you look at the world from outer space.
— lorazepam May 8, 06:47 AM #
Do something. If it doesn’t work, do something else. No idea is too crazy.
— purchase soma online infection interaxial May 8, 10:42 AM #
His priority did not seem to be to teach them what he knew, but rather to impress upon them that nothing, not even… knowledge, was foolproof.
— cheap valium May 8, 02:01 PM #
I’m moving, but don’t worry! [Someone once] told me we’re all on the same planet, so I’ll be okay!
— buy ultram online May 8, 05:43 PM #
It is curious that physical courage should be so common in the world and moral courage so rare.
— buy tramadol online May 9, 02:05 AM #
When you encounter difficulties and contradictions, do not try to break them, but bend them with gentleness and time.
— nasacort stooping polyforming May 9, 05:44 AM #
Even the fear of death is nothing compared to the fear of not having lived authentically and fully.
— order soma online May 9, 09:32 AM #
If you would thoroughly know anything, teach it to others.
— order adipex May 9, 01:17 PM #
You can’t deny laughter. When it comes, it plops down in your favorite chair and stays as long as it wants.
— order xanax May 9, 04:51 PM #